Old Dominion Curds: 7 Must-Try VA Cheeses for 2025

Old Dominion Curds: 7 Must-Try VA Cheeses for 2025

Virginia’s artisan cheese scene is flourishing, offering a diverse array of high-quality, locally-crafted cheeses. From the rolling hills of Loudoun County to the mountain farms of southwest Virginia, dedicated cheesemakers are creating unique flavors that reflect the region’s terroir.

These small-scale producers use traditional techniques and often source milk from their own grass-fed herds to create distinctive cheeses. Farms like Georges Mill in Lovettsville and Meadow Creek Dairy in the mountains of southwest Virginia exemplify this commitment to craftsmanship. Their products range from fresh, soft cheeses to aged, complex varieties that rival those from more established cheese-producing regions.

Supporting local cheesemakers not only provides access to fresh, flavorful cheese but also helps sustain Virginia’s agricultural heritage. Many farms welcome visitors by appointment, offering a chance to see the cheesemaking process firsthand and purchase directly from the source. Farmer’s markets and specialty shops throughout the state also showcase these artisanal products, making it easy for cheese enthusiasts to explore Virginia’s growing cheese culture.

History of Cheese in Virginia

A scenic Virginia landscape with rolling hills, a rustic farm, and a quaint cheese shop showcasing local artisan cheeses

Virginia’s cheese-making heritage spans centuries, evolving from small family farms to a thriving artisanal industry. The state’s diverse landscapes and agricultural traditions have shaped its unique cheese culture.

Early Cheese Production

Cheese production in Virginia dates back to colonial times. Early settlers brought cheese-making techniques from Europe, adapting them to local conditions. Small family farms produced cheese primarily for household consumption and local trade.

In the 18th and 19th centuries, dairy farming expanded across Virginia’s fertile valleys. Cheese became an important staple, with farmstead production methods passed down through generations. Cheddar and other hard cheeses were common due to their longer shelf life.

Rise of Artisanal Cheeses

The late 20th century saw a revival of artisanal cheese-making in Virginia. Small-scale producers began experimenting with traditional European recipes and local ingredients. This renaissance was driven by growing consumer interest in craft foods and sustainable agriculture.

Virginia’s artisan cheese scene flourished in the 2000s. Cheesemakers embraced the state’s terroir, creating unique flavors influenced by regional grasses and microclimates. Award-winning cheeses emerged, putting Virginia on the map of American artisanal cheese production.

Today, Virginia boasts over three dozen artisanal cheesemakers. They produce a wide variety of cheeses, from fresh chevre to aged raw milk varieties. Many have gained national recognition for their quality and innovation.

Understanding Artisan Cheese

A rustic wooden table displays a variety of Virginia local artisan cheeses, accompanied by fresh fruits, nuts, and a bottle of wine

Artisan cheese represents a pinnacle of craftsmanship in the dairy world. It embodies traditional techniques, high-quality ingredients, and meticulous attention to detail.

Defining Artisan Cheese

Artisan cheese is handcrafted in small batches by skilled cheesemakers. These cheeses often feature unique flavor profiles and textures not found in mass-produced varieties.

Artisan cheesemakers prioritize quality over quantity, using carefully selected milk sources. Many use raw milk, which retains natural enzymes and bacteria that contribute to complex flavors.

The production process involves minimal mechanization. Cheesemakers rely on their expertise to guide each step, from curdling to aging.

Artisan cheeses reflect their local environment, incorporating regional flavors and traditions. This connection to place gives each cheese a distinct character.

Characteristics of Farmstead Cheese

Farmstead cheese is a subset of artisan cheese made exclusively with milk from the cheesemaker’s own animals. This ensures complete control over the entire production process.

Farmstead cheeses often showcase seasonal variations in flavor and texture. These changes reflect the animals’ diets and environmental conditions throughout the year.

Many farmstead cheesemakers practice sustainable farming methods. They focus on animal welfare and environmental stewardship, which can contribute to the cheese’s quality.

Farmstead cheeses frequently highlight rare or heritage animal breeds. This practice helps preserve genetic diversity and traditional farming techniques.

The limited production scale of farmstead cheeses often results in unique, sought-after products. Cheese enthusiasts prize these for their authenticity and exceptional quality.

Types of Virginia Cheeses

A rustic wooden table displays a variety of Virginia artisan cheeses, surrounded by fresh herbs, fruits, and nuts

Virginia artisan cheesemakers craft a diverse array of high-quality cheeses using milk from cows, goats, and sheep. Each type offers unique flavors and textures influenced by the local terroir and traditional production methods.

Cow’s Milk Cheeses

Virginia’s cow’s milk cheeses showcase the rich flavors of the state’s lush pastures. Many farms use milk from grass-fed cows, resulting in cheeses with fresh, grassy notes. Peaceful Heart Farm produces a popular 100% grass-fed variety.

Some notable cow’s milk cheeses include:

  • Cheddar: Sharp and tangy versions aged for varying periods
  • Gouda: Smooth, sometimes smoked or flavored with herbs
  • Blue cheese: Creamy with distinctive blue veins and bold flavor

Award-winning options like Meadow Creek Dairy’s Grayson highlight Virginia’s cheesemaking expertise. This washed-rind cheese offers complex flavors reminiscent of European-style farmstead cheeses.

Goat’s Milk Cheeses

Goat cheese production has grown significantly in Virginia, with many farms specializing in this variety. The state’s goat cheeses range from fresh and tangy to aged and complex.

Popular styles include:

  • Chèvre: Soft, spreadable cheese with a mild flavor
  • Feta: Crumbly, salty cheese often used in salads
  • Aged goat cheese: Firm texture with nutty notes

Some producers create unique flavored versions by adding herbs, spices, or fruits. These artisanal goat cheeses have garnered attention at national competitions, showcasing Virginia’s cheesemaking prowess.

Sheep’s Milk Cheeses

While less common than cow and goat varieties, Virginia’s sheep’s milk cheeses offer rich, buttery flavors. These cheeses tend to have a higher fat content, resulting in a creamy texture.

Typical sheep’s milk cheeses found in Virginia include:

  • Pecorino-style: Hard, aged cheese with a sharp taste
  • Ricotta: Fresh, soft cheese with a mild flavor
  • Mixed milk cheeses: Blends sheep’s milk with cow or goat milk

Sheep’s milk cheeses from Virginia often appeal to cheese connoisseurs seeking distinctive flavors. Some local producers have received accolades for their innovative sheep’s milk creations.

Notable Cheese Producers

A rustic Virginia farm with rolling hills and grazing cows, surrounded by small artisan cheese production facilities

Virginia boasts several exceptional artisan cheese producers known for their high-quality, handcrafted offerings. These local cheesemakers combine traditional techniques with innovative approaches to create unique flavors that reflect the state’s terroir.

Meadow Creek Dairy

Meadow Creek Dairy, located in the Blue Ridge Mountains, specializes in raw milk cheeses. Their award-winning Grayson cheese is a washed-rind variety with a robust flavor profile. The dairy’s commitment to sustainable farming practices includes rotational grazing for their grass-fed cows.

Meadow Creek’s Appalachian cheese is another standout product, aged for 60 days and possessing a mild, nutty taste. The dairy’s focus on seasonal production ensures that their cheeses capture the essence of the pastures at different times of the year.

Caromont Farm

Caromont Farm, situated in Esmont, is renowned for its goat’s milk cheeses. Founder Gail Hobbs-Page has been instrumental in promoting Virginia’s artisan cheese scene. The farm’s signature Esmontonian is a semi-soft cheese with a delicate, tangy flavor.

Caromont’s Red Row cheese, washed with local wine, exemplifies the farm’s innovative approach. The farm also produces fresh chèvre and aged goat cheeses, each showcasing the distinct characteristics of their goat herd’s milk.

Georges Mill Farm

Georges Mill Farm, a family-owned operation in Lovettsville, produces small-batch goat cheeses. Their farmstead cheeses are made using milk from their own herd of Nubian and LaMancha goats. The farm’s Cavalry Camp cheese is a creamy, bloomy-rind variety with a rich flavor.

Georges Mill’s Catoctin is a tomme-style cheese aged for several months, developing complex flavors. The farm offers cheese-making classes and farm tours, allowing visitors to experience the artisanal process firsthand.

Cheesemaking in Virginia

Virginia’s artisan cheese industry blends traditional techniques with innovative approaches. Cheesemakers across the state craft unique flavors using locally sourced ingredients and sustainable practices.

Raw Milk and Pasteurization

Virginia cheesemakers use both raw and pasteurized milk in their creations. Raw milk cheeses, aged for at least 60 days, offer complex flavors and textures. These cheeses retain beneficial bacteria and enzymes that contribute to their distinct taste profiles.

Pasteurized milk cheeses are more common due to regulatory requirements. The pasteurization process ensures food safety while still allowing for diverse cheese varieties. Some cheesemakers use low-temperature pasteurization to preserve milk’s natural qualities.

Virginia’s cheese producers prioritize milk quality, often sourcing from local farms with grass-fed cows, goats, and sheep. This emphasis on high-quality milk contributes to the exceptional taste of Virginia cheeses.

Cultures and Techniques

Virginia cheesemakers employ a variety of cultures and techniques to create their artisanal products. Many use traditional starter cultures, including mesophilic and thermophilic bacteria, to develop flavor and texture.

Some producers experiment with wild fermentation, allowing native microbes to influence the cheese’s character. This approach results in unique, terroir-driven cheeses that reflect Virginia’s diverse microbial landscape.

Aging techniques vary widely among Virginia cheesemakers. Some age their cheeses in caves or specially designed aging rooms, carefully controlling temperature and humidity. Others use washed-rind techniques, brushing cheese surfaces with brine or alcohol to develop distinctive flavors.

Many Virginia cheesemakers are Certified Cheese Professionals, demonstrating their expertise in cheese production, aging, and flavor profiling. This certification ensures high standards of quality and knowledge throughout the state’s artisan cheese industry.

Sustainability and Animal Welfare

Virginia’s artisan cheesemakers prioritize sustainable practices and animal welfare. Their methods focus on responsible land management and raising healthy livestock to produce high-quality cheeses.

Pastures and Grazing

Virginia’s cheese producers utilize rotational grazing techniques. This practice allows pastures to regenerate between grazing periods. It also promotes soil health and biodiversity.

Cheesemakers often cultivate diverse grass species in their pastures. This provides a varied diet for livestock and enhances the flavor profile of the milk.

Some farms incorporate silvopasture systems. These integrate trees and grazing lands, offering shade for animals and additional environmental benefits.

Healthy Livestock

Artisan cheesemakers in Virginia prioritize the well-being of their animals. Many farms provide spacious, clean living conditions for their livestock.

Proper nutrition is essential. Farmers often supplement pasture grazing with locally-sourced feed to ensure balanced diets.

Regular veterinary check-ups and preventive care are standard practices. This helps maintain herd health and reduces the need for antibiotics.

Some Virginia cheese producers have obtained animal welfare certifications. These verify their commitment to ethical treatment of livestock.

Culinary Contributions and Pairings

A wooden board displays a variety of Virginia local artisan cheeses, accompanied by fresh fruits, nuts, and a bottle of wine

Virginia’s artisanal cheeses have become integral to the state’s culinary landscape. These locally-produced cheeses elevate dishes and pair beautifully with other regional products.

Virginia Cheese in Recipes

Virginia’s artisan cheeses add depth and flavor to many recipes. Creamy goat cheeses lend tanginess to salads and appetizers. Aged hard cheeses grate well over pasta dishes or into savory tarts.

Some chefs incorporate local cheeses into decadent macaroni and cheese. Others use them to create rich cheese sauces for steaks or vegetables. Virginia’s blue cheeses crumble nicely over salads or into dressings.

Baked dishes like quiches and gratins benefit from the complex flavors of aged cheddar or gouda-style cheeses. For desserts, fresh ricotta or mascarpone-style cheeses blend into cheesecakes or cannoli fillings.

Pairing with Local Products

Virginia’s artisan cheeses pair exceptionally well with other local products. The state’s wines complement many cheese styles. Crisp whites match fresh, tangy cheeses while full-bodied reds suit aged varieties.

Local honey drizzled over blue cheese creates a delightful sweet-salty contrast. Virginia-made chutneys and preserves accent cheese plates. The state’s craft ciders provide a refreshing counterpoint to rich, creamy cheeses.

Artisan crackers and breads from local bakeries serve as ideal vehicles for cheese tasting. Virginia-cured meats like ham or sausage create classic charcuterie pairings. For dessert, local chocolates or caramels match beautifully with aged cheeses.

Economic Impact and Tourism

A bustling farmers' market with a variety of artisan cheese vendors, surrounded by tourists and locals sampling and purchasing goods

Virginia’s local artisan cheese industry contributes significantly to the state’s economy and attracts tourists seeking authentic culinary experiences. The sector creates jobs, boosts revenue, and enhances the appeal of rural areas.

Cheese as an Economic Driver

Artisan cheese production in Virginia generates substantial economic benefits. The industry supports local dairy farms, creates jobs in cheese making and retail, and stimulates related businesses like packaging and distribution. In Southern Virginia, several small-scale cheese producers have revitalized rural economies.

Bonnyclabber Cheese, a notable producer in the region, employs local residents and sources milk from nearby farms. This local supply chain multiplies the economic impact, keeping money circulating within the community.

The artisan cheese sector also contributes to Virginia’s tax revenue. As part of the broader artisan industry, it helps generate millions in state taxes annually.

Agritourism and Cheese Tastings

Artisan cheese plays a crucial role in Virginia’s agritourism sector. Cheese farms and creameries attract visitors eager to experience the cheese-making process firsthand. Many offer tours, tastings, and workshops, providing additional revenue streams for producers.

Events centered around artisan cheese draw tourists to rural areas. Cheese festivals and farm-to-table dinners showcase local products and boost tourism in Southern Virginia. These events often feature Bonnyclabber Cheese and other regional producers.

Cheese tastings have become popular attractions, allowing visitors to sample and purchase directly from makers. This direct-to-consumer approach increases profit margins for producers and creates memorable experiences for tourists.

Supporting Local Cheese Makers

A picturesque countryside scene with rolling hills, a quaint cheese shop, and a local artisan proudly displaying their array of Virginia-made cheeses

Virginia’s artisan cheese industry is growing, and supporting local cheesemakers is crucial for its continued success. Consumers can play a vital role by purchasing directly from farm stores or farmers’ markets.

Georges Mill Farm, a family-operated dairy, encourages visitors to make appointments to buy their artisan cheese. This direct interaction allows customers to connect with producers and learn about their craft.

Peaceful Heart Farm, another local cheesemaker, uses traditional techniques to create high-quality products. They focus on sustainable practices, utilizing 100% grass-fed livestock including Normande and Jersey cows.

Ways to support local cheese makers:

  • Buy cheese directly from farms or farmers’ markets
  • Attend cheese tastings and events
  • Share information about local producers with friends and family
  • Include local cheeses in gift baskets or holiday celebrations

By choosing Virginia’s artisan cheeses, consumers contribute to the local economy and help preserve traditional cheesemaking methods. This support enables small-scale producers to continue crafting unique, high-quality products that reflect the region’s terroir.

Educating the public about the value of local cheese is essential. Understanding the artisanal process and the care that goes into each product can help justify the higher prices compared to mass-produced alternatives.