Ohio’s love affair with Buckeye candy runs deep, inspiring a statewide celebration of this beloved confection. The Buckeye Candy Challenge invites participants to explore the art of crafting these peanut butter and chocolate treats, honoring Ohio’s rich culinary heritage. This sweet competition showcases the creativity and skill of candy makers across the Buckeye State, highlighting the perfect balance of flavors in this iconic dessert.
The challenge extends beyond a simple contest, evolving into a cultural phenomenon that unites communities. Participants experiment with traditional recipes and innovative twists, pushing the boundaries of what a Buckeye candy can be. From local fairs to home kitchens, enthusiasts engage in friendly rivalry, each striving to create the most delectable version of Ohio’s signature sweet.
As the Buckeye Candy Challenge gains momentum, it has sparked the creation of the Ohio Buckeye Candy Trail. This curated journey takes candy lovers on a delightful adventure across the state, featuring 31 exceptional stops where they can savor diverse interpretations of the classic Buckeye. The trail not only satisfies sweet tooths but also promotes local businesses and showcases the charm of Ohio’s towns and cities.
History and Significance of Buckeye Candy
Buckeye candy holds a special place in Ohio’s cultural heritage, closely tied to the state’s natural symbol and beloved university. This confection’s origins and evolution reflect the pride and traditions of the Buckeye State.
Origins of the Name ‘Buckeye’
The term “buckeye” comes from the Native American word “hetuck,” meaning “eye of the buck.” In 1788, Colonel Ebenezer Sproat earned this nickname due to his impressive height when he opened the first court in Marietta, Ohio. The name stuck, becoming associated with Ohio residents and the state’s official tree.
The buckeye tree’s nuts resemble deer eyes, inspiring the candy’s distinctive appearance. In 1919, the Buckeye Candy Company in Brooklyn, Ohio, created the first official buckeye candy. This sweet treat combined chocolate and peanut butter to mimic the look of the buckeye nut.
Typical Celebrations and Events Featuring Buckeye Candy
Buckeye candy plays a prominent role in Ohio State University tailgates and football games. Fans often make or purchase these treats to share during pre-game festivities. The candy’s colors – brown chocolate and golden peanut butter center – match the university’s scarlet and gray.
During the holiday season, buckeyes become a staple in many Ohio homes. Families gather to make batches as part of their Christmas traditions. Local bakeries and candy shops see increased demand for buckeyes as gifts and party favors.
The Anthony Thomas Candy Company once created a massive 235-pound buckeye, showcasing the treat’s importance to Ohio’s identity. State fairs and food festivals often feature buckeye-making competitions or special buckeye-themed events.
Ingredients and Variations
Buckeye candy combines peanut butter and chocolate to create a beloved Ohio treat. The recipe allows for customization while maintaining its iconic appearance and flavors.
Key Ingredients
Creamy peanut butter forms the core of buckeye candy. Natural or regular peanut butter can be used, though natural varieties may require additional mixing. Confectioners’ sugar sweetens and binds the peanut butter mixture. Unsalted butter adds richness and helps achieve the right consistency.
For the outer layer, milk chocolate is traditional, but semisweet or dark chocolate can be substituted. Chocolate chips or melted chocolate bars work equally well. Some recipes incorporate a small amount of paraffin wax to give the coating a glossy finish and prevent melting at room temperature.
Variations of the Basic Recipe
Creative bakers have developed numerous twists on the classic buckeye. Some add crunchy elements like rice cereal or chopped nuts to the peanut butter center. Others experiment with flavors, incorporating vanilla extract, sea salt, or even bourbon for a grown-up version.
The chocolate coating can be customized by using white chocolate or adding a drizzle of contrasting chocolate on top. For a healthier option, some recipes reduce sugar content or use alternatives like honey or maple syrup. Vegan versions substitute plant-based butter and non-dairy chocolate.
Buckeye-inspired desserts include giant cookie versions, pies, and ice cream cakes that capture the essence of the original candy in new forms.
Making Buckeye Candy
Crafting delectable buckeye candy requires precision and attention to detail. The process involves creating a smooth peanut butter center, melting chocolate to the perfect consistency, and mastering dipping techniques for an attractive finish.
Mixing the Perfect Peanut Butter Center
The heart of buckeye candy lies in its creamy peanut butter center. Combine 1 1/2 cups of creamy peanut butter with 1 cup of softened butter in a large bowl. Mix until smooth. Gradually add 4 cups of powdered sugar, beating until fully incorporated. The mixture should be firm enough to roll into balls.
Roll the peanut butter mixture into 1-inch balls. Place them on a wax paper-lined baking sheet. Insert a toothpick into each ball for easier handling during the dipping process. Chill the balls in the freezer for about 30 minutes to firm them up.
Melting Chocolate to the Ideal Consistency
Proper chocolate melting is crucial for a smooth coating. Use 4 cups of semi-sweet chocolate chips for dipping. Melt the chocolate in a double boiler or microwave, stirring frequently to ensure even heating.
For microwave melting, heat in 30-second intervals, stirring between each. The ideal consistency is smooth and glossy, with no lumps. Avoid overheating, as it can cause the chocolate to seize or burn.
Dipping and Coating Techniques
Dip chilled peanut butter balls into melted chocolate, leaving a small circle of peanut butter exposed at the top to resemble a buckeye nut. Hold the ball by the toothpick and gently tap off excess chocolate.
For best results, dip quickly to maintain the ball’s shape. If the chocolate starts to cool and thicken, reheat it briefly. Work in small batches to keep the peanut butter balls chilled between dipping.
Finishing Touches and Presentation
After dipping, return the buckeyes to the wax paper-lined sheet. Carefully remove the toothpicks and smooth over the holes with a small spatula or your finger. Chill the buckeyes in the refrigerator until the chocolate sets completely, about 1 hour.
For gifting, place buckeyes in mini cupcake liners and arrange in a decorative tin or box. Store buckeyes in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks. Bring to room temperature before serving for the best flavor and texture.
Preserving Buckeye Candy
Proper storage is key to maintaining the quality and flavor of buckeye candies. Effective preservation methods allow these treats to be enjoyed long after the holiday season.
Optimal Storage Conditions
Buckeye candies can be stored at room temperature for up to two weeks. Place them in an airtight container to prevent moisture and odors from affecting their taste. Keep the container in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and heat sources.
For longer storage, refrigeration is recommended. Place buckeyes in a sealed plastic container or resealable bag. Separate layers with wax paper to prevent sticking. Refrigerated buckeyes will stay fresh for up to one month.
Freezing and Thawing Methods
Freezing extends the shelf life of homemade buckeyes significantly. Place cooled candies in a single layer on a baking sheet and freeze until solid. Transfer to freezer-safe containers or bags, separating layers with parchment paper.
Label containers with the date. Frozen buckeyes remain good for 3-6 months. To thaw, move the desired amount to the refrigerator for several hours or overnight. Let them come to room temperature before serving for the best texture and flavor.
Buckeye Candy in Ohio Culture
Buckeye candy holds a special place in Ohio’s cultural identity. This beloved treat connects deeply with the state’s heritage, university traditions, and social gatherings.
Connection to Ohio State University
Ohio State University embraces the buckeye as its mascot and symbol. Students, alumni, and fans often enjoy buckeye candies at tailgates and game day parties. The candies’ resemblance to buckeye nuts creates a tangible link to the university’s spirit.
Many campus shops and nearby stores sell buckeye candies year-round. During football season, sales spike as fans stock up for game day celebrations.
The Ohio State University Marching Band even performs a formation called “Script Ohio” where they spell out “Ohio” on the field. This iconic moment often inspires buckeye-themed treats at viewing parties.
Continuing Tradition at Social Gatherings
Buckeye candies frequently appear at Ohio social events. Holiday parties, potlucks, and family reunions often feature platters of these chocolate-peanut butter treats.
Many Ohioans learn to make buckeyes from family recipes passed down through generations. The act of creating buckeyes together has become a cherished tradition for many families.
Some creative bakers incorporate buckeye flavors into other desserts. Buckeye brownies, cookies, and even buckeye-inspired wedding cakes have gained popularity.
The Ohio Buckeye Candy Trail
The Ohio Buckeye Candy Trail highlights top spots for buckeye treats across the state. This self-guided tour encourages locals and visitors to explore Ohio’s candy-making heritage.
Stops on the trail include:
- Marsha’s Homemade Buckeyes in Perrysburg
- Haute Chocolate in Columbus
- Sweet Tooth Cottage in Powell
Each location offers its own unique take on the classic buckeye. Some feature gourmet variations with sea salt, dark chocolate, or even buckeye-inspired truffles.
The trail promotes small businesses and introduces travelers to charming Ohio towns. It has become a popular activity for food enthusiasts and families seeking a sweet adventure.
Where to Find Buckeye Candy
Ohio offers numerous options for finding delectable buckeye candies. From local confectioners to online retailers, these peanut butter and chocolate treats are readily available across the state and beyond.
Local Sweet Shops and Artisans
Many Ohio sweet shops specialize in handcrafted buckeye candies. Anthony-Thomas Candy Company in Columbus is renowned for its buckeyes, which feature a white chocolate cap.
Esther Price Candies in Dayton offers their take on the classic treat. Winans Chocolates + Coffees, with multiple locations, is another popular choice for buckeye enthusiasts.
Buckeye Donuts in Columbus puts a unique spin on the candy by offering a buckeye-themed donut. This creative adaptation satisfies both donut lovers and buckeye aficionados.
Greater’s Ice Cream serves up buckeye-inspired frozen treats. Their Buckeye Madness flavor combines vanilla custard with Reese’s Cups, chocolate syrup, and peanut butter.
Online Stores and Specialty Websites
For those unable to visit Ohio in person, online options abound. Many local confectioners offer shipping services through their websites.
Experience Columbus has launched the Columbus Buckeye Treat Trail, a digital guide to exploring buckeye treats in the city. This resource helps both locals and visitors discover various buckeye candy options.
Specialty food websites often feature buckeye candies from different Ohio artisans. These platforms allow candy lovers to compare and purchase buckeyes from multiple makers in one place.
Some online retailers offer buckeye-making kits for those who want to try their hand at creating these treats at home. These kits typically include ingredients and instructions for crafting authentic Ohio buckeyes.
